Skip to main content

Table 6 Outcomes post-intervention and 3 and 6 months post-intervention adjusted for baseline characteristics

From: Group music therapy with songwriting for adult patients with long-term depression (SYNCHRONY study): a feasibility and acceptability study of the intervention and parallel randomised controlled trial design with wait-list control and nested process evaluation

 

Post-intervention

3 months

6 months

Treatment group N = 10

Wait-list group N = 9

Treatment group N = 9

Wait-list group N = 9

Treatment group N = 10

Wait-list group N = 8

Mean

95% CI

Mean

95% CI

Mean

95% CI

Mean

95% CI

Mean

95% CI

Mean

95% CI

MADRS

31.28

25.03

37.53

25.51

18.95

32.08

19.82

13.36

26.28

23.51

17.04

29.98

24.91

18.79

31.03

23.31

16.46

30.16

BDI-II

35.87

30.03

41.71

28.61

22.46

34.75

30.72

22.97

38.48

29.60

21.83

37.36

34.08

27.30

40.85

29.03

21.45

36.62

CSQ

21.36

17.48

25.24

21.41

17.31

25.51

21.46

16.84

26.08

22.86

18.24

27.47

22.56

17.69

27.43

20.17

14.71

25.62

MANSA

3.35

2.87

3.83

3.43

2.92

3.94

3.89

3.59

4.20

3.55

3.24

3.85

3.67

3.19

4.16

3.41

2.87

3.96

RSES

19.45

17.53

21.37

22.31

20.28

24.34

23.73

21.17

26.28

23.20

20.65

25.75

21.95

19.45

24.46

24.10

21.30

26.90

GPSES

22.93

20.14

25.72

25.01

22.07

27.95

25.20

22.44

27.96

25.12

22.35

27.88

22.94

20.52

25.37

23.29

20.58

26.01

WSAS

27.82

24.20

31.44

24.96

21.14

28.77

27.71

21.59

33.83

27.07

20.92

33.22

28.69

24.94

32.45

24.16

19.98

28.34

BSI SOM

2.08

1.65

2.51

2.09

1.64

2.54

1.36

0.81

1.90

2.04

1.49

2.60

1.73

1.29

2.17

1.78

1.29

2.28

BSI OC

2.84

2.36

3.32

2.28

1.78

2.78

2.47

1.91

3.04

2.17

1.60

2.74

2.70

2.20

3.21

2.33

1.76

2.89

BSI IIS

2.28

1.87

2.68

2.26

1.84

2.68

2.15

1.44

2.85

2.89

2.18

3.59

2.18

1.89

2.46

2.28

1.96

2.60

BSI DEP

2.50

2.03

2.96

2.37

1.88

2.87

2.40

1.84

2.97

2.66

2.09

3.23

2.42

1.97

2.86

2.57

2.07

3.06

BSI ANX

2.07

1.66

2.47

1.84

1.41

2.26

1.96

1.35

2.56

2.14

1.53

2.75

2.24

1.89

2.59

1.92

1.53

2.31

BSI HOS

1.74

1.24

2.24

1.88

1.35

2.40

1.71

1.29

2.14

2.07

1.64

2.50

2.00

1.44

2.56

1.77

1.15

2.40

BSI PHOB

2.34

2.01

2.67

1.89

1.55

2.24

2.14

1.67

2.60

1.96

1.49

2.43

2.25

1.84

2.66

2.09

1.63

2.55

BSI PAR

2.31

1.90

2.73

2.16

1.73

2.60

2.36

2.04

2.68

2.37

2.05

2.69

2.39

2.11

2.67

2.15

1.83

2.47

BSI PSY

2.57

2.13

3.01

2.39

1.92

2.85

2.56

2.02

3.11

2.29

1.75

2.84

2.56

2.18

2.94

2.74

2.32

3.16

BSI GSI

1.87

1.57

2.17

1.77

1.45

2.08

1.71

1.36

2.05

1.82

1.47

2.16

1.95

1.69

2.21

1.73

1.44

2.02

BSI PST

38.85

34.16

43.53

38.21

33.25

43.17

35.37

30.12

40.62

39.10

33.80

44.40

39.73

35.06

44.39

37.40

32.21

42.59

BSI PSDI

2.37

2.12

2.62

2.31

2.05

2.57

2.27

2.00

2.54

2.33

2.06

2.60

2.39

2.17

2.60

2.27

2.03

2.51

LSP CAR

31.11

29.15

33.06

33.67

31.62

35.73

35.12

33.68

36.57

33.56

32.11

35.01

35.82

34.05

37.60

33.06

31.08

35.05

LSP NON

39.18

36.86

41.50

42.75

40.31

45.19

43.89

42.12

45.66

44.64

42.87

46.42

45.46

43.26

47.66

44.89

42.43

47.35

LSP SOC

13.45

11.56

15.33

15.67

13.68

17.66

13.93

11.37

16.49

14.78

12.22

17.34

15.47

13.34

17.59

15.93

13.56

18.31

LSP COM

21.69

20.53

22.85

22.59

21.37

23.81

22.31

21.41

23.22

22.14

21.24

23.05

22.30

21.55

23.04

22.22

21.39

23.06

LSP RESP

16.52

15.69

17.34

18.35

17.49

19.22

18.50

17.56

19.45

17.57

16.63

18.52

18.26

17.01

19.52

18.42

17.02

19.83

LSP SUM

122.34

117.45

127.23

132.68

127.55

137.81

134.23

129.26

139.20

132.34

127.36

137.33

137.60

132.12

143.08

133.91

127.78

140.05

Back to article page

Pilot and Feasibility Studies

ISSN: 2055-5784