Skip to main content

Table 3 Feasibility results for this pilot review

From: Mapping the nomenclature, methodology, and reporting of studies that review methods: a pilot methodological review

Measure

Target

Observed

Description

Sensitivity/specificityb

≥ 70%

Sensitivity, 100%

Specificity, 0.99%

Six terms combined gave good sensitivity but compromised specificity

Published protocolsa

≤ 70%

22.6%

Few studies had pre-specified methods

Coefficient of variationc

~ 1

0.8

Fairly consistent number of databases searched

Justification of search limitsa

≤ 70%

25.8%

Few studies justified their search limits

Justification of sample size or perform sample size calculationa

≤ 70%

16.1%

Few studies justified their sample sizes or performed calculations

Use a random sampling approachc

≤ 70%

100%

All studies adopted a random sampling approach

Discuss the generalizability of findingsa

≤ 70%

9.7%

Few studies described how generalizable their findings were

  1. aFeasibility criteria met
  2. bFeasibility criteria partially met
  3. cFeasibility criteria not met