Skip to main content

Table 1 Table indicating feasibility, clinical, operational, and economic outcome variables

From: A protocol for a pilot cluster randomized control trial of e-vouchers and mobile phone application to enhance access to maternal health services in Cameroon

Outcome measures

Scale

Type

Measure

Method of analysis

Feasibility outcomes

Evaluate randomization

Ordinal

Binary

% of health areas with successful stratification and randomization

Feasibility threshold of 95%

Enrolment rate

Nominal

Binary

% of participants with successful enrolment within 6 months into the trial

Feasibility threshold of 50%

Complete follow-up

Ratio

Continuous

% of participants who complete follow-up at 8months into the trial

Feasibility threshold of 80%

Compliance rate

Ratio

Continuous

% of participants who do not follow procedure as allocated

Feasibility threshold of 10%

Contamination

Ratio

Continuous

% of contamination

Feasibility threshold of 10%

Refusal rate

Ratio

Continuous

% of participants who refused to respond

Feasibility threshold of 5%

Adherence rate

Ratio

Continuous

% of participants who adheres to the intervention

Feasibility threshold of 80%

Clinical outcomes

Failure rate

Ratio

Continuous

% of participants whom intervention (mobile phone features) failed to function according to design

n (%)

Mortality

Ratio

Binary

Number of maternal deaths

n (%)

Number of ANC visits

Nominal

Binary

Number of ANC visits attended

Mean (SD)

Number of skilled birth delivery

Nominal

Binary

Number of skilled birth delivery

Mean (SD)

Family planning

Nominal

Binary

% using family planning/awareness

n (%)

Operational outcomes

Resource capacity

Nominal

Binary

Average number of human resources

Mean (SD)

Equipment availability

Nominal

Binary

Average number of equipment

n (%)

District and health areas capacity

Nominal

Binary

% of resource functionality and communication network

n (%)

Project timelines

Nominal

Binary

Average length of follow-up

Mean (SD)

Data collection time

Nominal

continuous

Average time to collect data

Mean (SD)

Matching data from other sources

Nominal

binary

% of success in matching data sources

n (%)

Data completeness

Nominal

Binary

% of participants who do not provide complete response

n (%)

Acceptability of using mhealth and e-vouchers by participants

Nominal

Binary

% of participants who accept the use mhealth

N (%)

Acceptability of using mhealth and e-vouchers by providers

Nominal

Binary

% of providers who accept the use of mhealth

N (%)

Use of transportation vouchers

Nominal

Binary

% of women using transportation vouchers

N (%)

Economic outcomes

Total cost of care

Ratio

Continuous

Average total cost of care

Mean (SD)

Cost per woman enrolled

Ratio

Continuous

Average total cost of care per woman enrolled

Mean (SD)

Additional cost due to emergencies

Ratio

Continuous

% with additional emergency cost

n (%)