Skip to main content

Table 2 Primary outcome analysis

From: Study protocol: design and rationale for an exploratory phase II randomized controlled trial to determine optimal vitamin D3 supplementation strategies for acute fracture healing

Objective

Hypothesis

Fracture healing outcome

Method of analysis

To determine the response of vitamin D3 dose on fracture healing at 3 months

High doses of supplementation (loading or daily) will increase healing compared to low daily dose. Using high doses will rapidly increase the circulating vitamin D available during fracture callus formation.

1. FIX-IT (clinical)

Patients in the high loading dose and high daily dose groups will be combined for a 2:1 comparison against low daily dose group using an independent t-test (alpha = 0.20).*

2. RUST (radiographic)

3. PINP (biologic)

4. CTX (biologic)

To determine the response of vitamin D3 frequency on fracture healing at 3 months

High loading dose increases healing compared to high daily dose. Loading doses will overcome medication adherence issues and increase circulating vitamin D even more rapidly than daily doses.

1. FIX-IT (clinical)

Comparisons between the high loading dose and high daily dose groups will be made using an independent t-test (alpha = 0.20).*

2. RUST (radiographic)

3. PINP (biologic)

4. CTX (biologic)

To determine the response of low amounts of vitamin D3 supplementation on fracture healing at 3 months

Low daily dose will increase healing compared to placebo. While the low daily dose is not expected to increase circulating vitamin D as rapidly as the high dose strategies, this comparison will determine if rapid serum increases are necessary to improve fracture healing.

1. FIX-IT (clinical)

Comparisons between the low daily dose and placebo groups will be made using an independent t-test (alpha = 0.20).*

2. RUST (radiographic)

3. PINP (biologic)

4. CTX (biologic)

  1. *Using a phase II screening trial approach, comparisons are non-definitive and an increased alpha level has been adopted